What is the most expensive beanie baby?

Answer by  Hank (117)

The most expensive beanie baby is Peanut the royal blue elephant. The first 2000 were made darker then the rest making them rare. The value is roughly 4,500

Answer by  Roland27 (16334)

Peanut the elephant in royal blue. It was a factory mistake it is worth about $4,500. Since the Beanie Baby Craze is on hiatus most are worth hardly anything.

Answer by  raja86 (86)

Check out Ebay and other auction sites for this information. The values chnace frequently. You can also contact the TY manufacturing website. Prices vary greatly around the country. They wer much more valuable in he late nineties, and each year the one that was the most valuable changed.

Answer by  Tom57 (113)

The most expensive beanie baby is the royal Blue peanut. This had a production error, making them a darker blue than expected and have very low quantities.